Scaling a Gift Shop in NYC - Annie's Blue Ribbon General Store with Ann Cantrell

Ann Cantrell thought she was building a career in fashion. She spent over a decade in product development at Ralph Lauren, Coach, and Brooks Brothers, turning sketches into products and learning the vendor, margin, and production game. But all the while, she was quietly stockpiling binders of ideas, gift products, fixtures, and concepts, planning for the day she’d open her own store.

In 2007, after securing a $150K home-equity loan and leaving corporate life behind, Ann opened Annie’s Blue Ribbon General Store in a 520 sq ft “vanilla box” in Boerum Hill, Brooklyn. Ann ran the shop by day and freelanced on Mondays and Thursday mornings to make ends meet. Six years later, she moved into a bigger 1,100 sq ft space on Fifth Avenue in Park Slope, quadrupling her foot traffic and planting herself on what Time Out later named the “coolest street in New York City.”

Nearly 18 years in, Blue Ribbon is thriving, up ~40% since pre-COVID, with tens of thousands of SKUs, thousands of vendors, and a team of four full-timers and eight part-timers. Ann balances the store with her role as a professor at FIT, where she teaches sustainability and fashion merchandising, while still doing what she loves most: "zhuzhing" the shelves, curating seasonal stories, and building community through happy-hour Thursdays, mahjong cohorts, and even a cult-favorite $1 NCRT print machine that draws collectors citywide.

We cover:

• How Ann pivoted from corporate fashion to independent retail
• The 10-year “always be planning” phase before opening in 2007
• Breaking down the $150K opening budget: rent, website, and inventory
• Why she chose a no-frills vanilla box over a costly buildout
• Lessons from moving to Park Slope and quadrupling foot traffic
• Operating at scale: tens of thousands of SKUs, thousands of vendors
• Structuring a small but mighty team (buyer/GM, logistics, store, marketing)
• Surviving COVID and coming out 40% stronger with online + events
• Why candles, cards, and candy remain the top sellers
• The philosophy of one extraordinary store > many average ones

If you’re curious about what it really takes to open and sustain an independent retail gift store in NYC, this episode is packed with hard numbers, survival tactics, merchandising insights, and community-building lessons from someone who’s been building in Brooklyn for nearly two decades.

Resources & Links
Annie’s Blue Ribbon General Store: https://www.blueribbongeneralstore.com/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/anniesblueribbongeneralstore

Sponsored by Signs and Mirrors, the leading sign and furniture shop for retail stores.

Opening Soon Links & Resources
→ Signs and furniture for retail stores: https://signsandmirrors.com
→ NYC and Houston’s first self-portrait studio: https://fotolab.studio
→ Follow us on Instagram: @openingsoonpodcast
→ More episodes and guest info: https://www.openingsoonpodcast.com
→ Your Host Alan Li: https://www.linkedin.com/in/alan-li-711a8629/